
We saw Charlie Wilson's war and I'm told that Tom Hanks had Charlie Wilson down. Too bad, the movie didn't have the truth about Afghanistan down as well. For one thing, did you notice that Pres. Reagan was no where to be found?
Dr. Jack Wheeler in last weeks To The Point News newsletter (By subscription only) wrote that it was not Joanne Herring (played by Ms. Roberts), but Wheeler himself, that told Wilson "defeating the Soviets in Afghanistan could win the Cold War."
The movie makes clear that the State Department in Pakistan is not interested in winning in Afghanistan by defeating the Russians. Then the only one the CIA operative, Phillip Seymour Hoffman, mentions as a recipient for aid is Afghani Ahmad Shah Massoud. Wheeler writes
Yet the CIA in fact provided little or no aid to Massoud for most of the war. The film never mentions who did get most of the CIA aid instead of Massoud: an America-hating Khomeini-loving Islamofascist named Gulbuddin Hekmatyar, and his "Hezbi" Mujahaddin.
Here's what Dr. Jack Wheeler writes:
How the Afghans got the Stingers that won the war is a fascinating story never fully told and can only be abbreviated here. The very condensed version is this:
All the massive weapons flow organized by Charlie and the CIA had, by mid-1986, done no good as it was mostly going to Gulbuddin. When I was in Afghanistan in August, the war was over. The Soviets had won, most of the Muj had retreated back to the refugee camps in Pakistan. Soviet Spetsnaz teams were hunting down and killing the Muj who were left.
Ronald Reagan had been well aware of the need for shoulder-fired heat-seeking missiles, and in April 1985 signed a classified Executive Order giving CIA Director Bill Casey the authority to provide the Muj with Stingers. The EO was blocked by CIA Deputy Director John McMahon.
McMahon was determined that the Afghans not get Stingers, and used every bureaucratic trick in the book in a constant stream of excuses to prevent their delivery, despite the demands of Reagan, Senator Gordon Humphrey (R-NH), Charlie, and many others in Congress such as Don Ritter (R-PA).
By late 1985, the entire conservative movement was demanding military aid to anti-Soviet freedom fighters, so we decided to make an end run around McMahon. A visit by UNITA leader Jonas Savimbi was arranged to Washington, where he met President Reagan in the Oval Office on January 30, 1986.
Savimbi told Reagan about the coming Soviet-Cuban offensive scheduled at the end of the rainy season in April, that UNITA would be destroyed without Stingers against the Hinds. Reagan gave Savimbi his word that the Stingers would be provided.
The President then called Bill Casey and said he just didn't care what the excuses were anymore. Any reason given by McMahon was to be disregarded. He signed an EO to that effect on February 18. Two weeks later, McMahon resigned. I was in Angola at UNITA's Jamba headquarters in April when the Stingers arrived. The Soviet-Cuban offensive was stopped thanks to them.
Now, that's a far cry from the story in the movie. Charlie Wilson, a Democrat, who
died retired in 1997,(Upon leaving Congress, Wilson retired to Lufkin, Texas, where he now lives (as of 2007)). In February 1999, Wilson married Barbara Alberstadt, a former ballerina he first met at a party in Washington in 1980.
In September 2007, after two years on a waiting list for a transplant, Wilson was the recipient of a heart from a 35-year-old donor. loved this country and found a way to fight the Communists in Afghanistan. He didn't fight alone and he fought against the CIA elites who were wrong then as they have been, at least publicly, so many times since. It's a shame that the movie isn't deeper.
The final scene is one of Wilson seeking $1 million for schools in Afghanistan, after we spent $500 million on weapons. He was turned down because "no one gives a shit about schools" for Afghanis. That seems to be the Movie's lesson for Americans to the question, "Why do they hate us?" We didn't spend enough money building them back up so the Taliban (Hamas or Palastinians, your choice) marched in.
Wheeler writes that Charlie Wilson's heroism should be "a deep embarrassment to the party of Pelosi Galore and Lost Harry Reid, the party who apologizes for America's existence and has neither the spine nor will to defend her."
Charlie Wilson Charlie Wilson's War Mover Mike
Update: